Which is better roofing nails or staples

After all, it’s no surprise roofers loved staples for attaching shingles to roofing. Staples cost less than nails, offer exceptional holding strength, and cover a greater area of space with a more versatile and compact collation. … Breaking it down further, you’ll typically use four fasteners per 3-tab shingle.

Is it better to nail or staple roof shingles?

Roofing nails are highly preferred to staples for asphalt and other types of roofs because they offer more holding power, meet building codes, and are easier to install correctly.

Can you use a staple gun on roof shingles?

While it used to be common practice to use staples to attach asphalt shingles to a roof, this has been a prohibited method of attachment in Minnesota since 2003. … Staple guns are smaller and better balanced. Coil nail guns are literally fed with a coil of nails, and the holder for the nails makes the gun much bulkier.

Are nails better than staples?

Nail Gun Tasks Nails are less visible once applied than staples, and easier to remove, with less damage. Nail guns also attach sheathing, like plywood to roof rafters or to framing. The downside is that nails wiggle out of wood with changes in temperature and humidity more easily than staples.

Is a hand nailed roof better?

Some roofers believe hand-nailing shingles gives them more control over the process. They can use “feel” to determine if the nail is deep enough and in the right location. Since hand-nailing takes a bit more time, they have the chance to correct any mistakes on the spot. On the other hand, labor costs will be higher.

Are nail guns bad for roofing?

Over-pressured or under-pressured nail guns can cause over-driven nails. This brings potential risk and damage to your shingle roof. Nails that are applied too deep can cut the fiber-mat inside of the shingle, which can reduce their resistance to withstand high winds.

Do staples damage shingles?

Staples damage your shingles. Tiny holes from repeated stapling will limit the lifespan of your roof considerably. Asphalt shingles will lose granules much quicker this way, and wooden shingles can splinter and even rot away from underneath if water seeps beneath them.

Can I use staples for roof felt?

Staples can be used for tacking it down, but not recommended to hold. When the shingles are installed the felt is not going anywhere. Back in the day all I used was staples and /or roofing nails now plastic tops are the norm.

Can you use staples on a roof?

Fasteners for asphalt shingles should be roofing nails or staples. … Both nails and staples have sufficient strength to resist small uplift load on the shingles, as long as the tabs remain sealed. If staples are properly installed, they offer nearly the same wind resistance as nails.

Can you staple roof sheeting?

If 8d “common” nails are specified, the nail diameter must be at least 0.131 inch (wider than typical 8d pneumatic nails). Screws can be used for even greater withdrawal strength, but should be sized by the building designer. Staples are not recommended for roof sheathing attachment in high-wind areas.

Article first time published on

What size staples do you use for roofing?

Staples made of at least 16-gauge galvanized steel with a minimum crown of 15/16” (24 mm) have been and continue to be used by some applicators to install shingles.

What nails do you use for shingles?

Galvanized roofing nails tend to resist rust formation, and they are a suitable option for asphalt shingles. Owens Corning requires using either galvanized steel, stainless steel, or aluminum nails to affix shingles.

What kind of nail gun do you use for shingles?

Shingles should be mechanically fastened with a pneumatic nail gun if the contractor determines that the roof sheathing is consistent and free from gaps. Most roof systems with plywood or OSB sheathing will fall into this category.

Why is hand nailing shingles better?

Hand driving nails into shingles allows for the roofer to place the nail on the proper nail line and then drive the nail in. Ensuring that the nails are properly placed each and every time because the head of the hammer stops flush on top of the shingles.

Can I use a framing nailer for roofing?

Large-body nailers typically include framing nailers and roofing nailers. These nailers are used for more technical projects such as framing out a basement or installing roofing shingles. … If you’re constructing a fence, a framing nailer is a good option.

How long should roofing nails be?

Roofing nails should be 1-1/4 to 2 inches long to ensure that it sufficiently penetrates and embeds in the roof sheathing. To calculate the appropriate roofing nail length, add the thickness of the shingles and underlayment to the thickness of the sheathing. Nail shank diameter should be at least 11-12 gauge for roofs.

What do roof nails look like?

All roofing nails have wide, flat heads and short shanks. The tips of the nails are sharp and pointed for easy insertion so you don’t break the shingles or damage the wood when driving the nails through. Different roofing materials require different types of roofing nails.

Are Christmas lights bad for shingles?

Fans of the movie Christmas Vacation will recall Clark Griswold putting up his lights with his trusty staple gun. Don’t do that. Stapling to your eaves (the wood part around the perimeter of your roof) is probably okay. But avoid putting staples or nails or screws or any type of hole into your shingles.

How long are roofing nails for shingles?

Proper Nail Application For Asphalt Shingles Nails should have a minimum, nominal shank diameter of 11- or 12-gauge, and a minimum head diameter of three-eighths of an inch. The length of each nail must be a minimum of 1¼ inches long, and for roof-overs, Atlas recommends a nail length of at least 2 inches.

Do you nail shingles?

Because the thickness, weight, and shape of shingles vary, manufacturer’s instructions vary slightly. But virtually all manufacturers agree that nails should be installed below the adhesive strip. To keep a warranty intact, follow the manufacturer’s nailing and installation instructions closely.

How much should shingles overlap drip edge?

Shingles should not extend more than 3/4” (19 mm) past the drip edge. If shingles overhang the edge of the roof by more than 3/4” (19 mm), then they are not supported and may crack and break off. In addition, the wind resistance at the roof edge may be compromised.

Can I nail down loose shingles?

Be sure to nail back down any undamaged shingles that had to be loosened to release damaged shingles. Seal each nail head with a bit of roofing cement.

What is the best fastener to use for composite shingles?

Nails should be corrosion-resistant, wide-head roofing nails of the proper length. Corrosion-resistant nails can be made of galvanized steel, copper, aluminum or stainless steel. Fasteners should not be over-driven, which will cause them to cut part-way through the shingle and lower its wind resistance.

Can a siding nailer be used for roofing?

Both tools are coil nailers that are built to drive nails into wood, but you can’t use them interchangeably. … Each nailer is named for the job they fill. Siding nailers are for installing siding and roofing nailers are meant for installing roofing.

How many nails do I need for roofing felt?

Drive about five nails in the top right-hand corner and roll out the felt about halfway (perhaps 25 feet) across the roof. Stand on the first course of felt and work with the second course of felt above you. It is not necessary to completely nail the top edge of the course.

What nails do you use for roofing felt?

Galvanised nails can be used in a wide range of applications, but are most commonly used in the installation of asphalt shingles and felt on outbuildings, sheds and more – wherever adverse weather conditions are common, galvanised nails are a good choice.

What kind of stapler is used for sheathing?

Medium crown staplers are designed for applications including sheathing, roofing, vinyl siding, furniture framing, crate and pallet assembly.

Can you use staples on OSB?

For example, according to the table, 7/16″ OSB (Oriented Strand Board) wall sheathing may be fastened with 6d common, box or casing nails OR 1-3/4″ 16 gage staples at 6″ on center at the panel edges and 12″ on center in the field (special conditions apply for shear walls).

What is a crown stapler?

A crown stapler is essentially a staple gun. It uses staples instead of nails, which is what is used by a nail gun. … It is a permanent fastening solution that uses staples with a round or flat head. This allows for a strong hold when fastening material to a wood surface such as upholstery.

What is the shortest roofing nail?

You are required to penetrate (per code) into the sheathing 3/4 of an inch with your nail, meaning the smallest is 13/16, or for simplicity 7/8 is realistically the smallest you should use. So 5/8″ is the shortest nail made for roofs, however to use them is a code violation the majority of the time.

Can you staple lights to shingles?

When you’re hanging Christmas lights on a roof, you shouldn’t use any fasteners that puncture the shingle or any other part of the roof, such as nails, staples or screws. Even small holes in the shingles can create leaks.